“Living Among the Breakage”
On the Meaning of T.S. Eliot
God does not stand aloof, waiting for us to attain perfection; as Eliot’s best poems reveal, God appears suddenly in the ruins, “among the breakage” of our profoundly imperfect lives.
T.S. Eliot knew all about life in the ruins. He lived in England through the First World War. Then the second one came, and in July 1940, he joined up as an Air Raid Precautions warden for London. That autumn, the Blitz began, and for eight months German planes pounded English cities with bombs. On a London rooftop, warden Eliot kept a weekly nighttime fire watch, and saw the spreading devastation that left around 43,000 civilians dead. It must have felt like the end of the world.
But he had private ruins too. Eliot’s first marriage became a long, slow catastrophe. And there are fresh revelations about his complicated romantic life. The sordid side of the poet troubles us because Eliot has gained canonical status as a Christian poet and intellectual. Lyndall Gordon’s biography, T.S. Eliot: An Imperfect Life, takes frank stock of these uglier moments in the great writer’s story, and addresses this apparent “divide between saint and sinner."1 On the one hand, the Nobel-Prize-winning Eliot was a devout Anglican convert who wrote some of the greatest mystical poetry in our language. On the other hand, he also penned obscene and racist verse, indulged in antisemitism, and left behind him a wake of ruined relationships with women.
Gordon charts Eliot’s literary work against the poet’s biography, and she argues that Eliot’s writing dramatizes “a consuming search for salvation,” a quest for what she calls “the perfect life” (pp. 4, 333). This quest, as the title of her book reveals, was a heroic failure, for Eliot never could fully extricate himself from the wreckage of his sin and wounds. Even if his best work pointed the way to God, for Gordon, Eliot never could “match the perfect life to which he aspired” (p. 3). Eliot doubtless felt this way himself sometimes, as we all do. But as we will see, Gordon’s focus on Eliot as a failed saint misses the scandalous Christian truth in Eliot’s poetry and in the Gospel: that the Christian God does not wait for us to escape our brokenness: rather, he comes to meet us precisely in the very ruins of our lives.
Thomas Stearns Eliot was born in St. Louis in 1888, the youngest of seven children. A New England Brahmin clan, the Eliots had blood ties to people as famous as John Adams, Noah Webster, Herman Melville, and Louisa May Alcott. He spent his first sixteen years in Missouri, until his family relocated to Boston. In 1906 he entered Harvard to study the humanities, where he read Dante in Italian. It is in Boston that Gordon locates the origins of Eliot’s spiritual quest. It began with dissatisfaction: “Bred in a family which belongs at the very heart of Boston Unitarianism, Eliot’s fervent nature found no nourishment there, and by the time he enrolled at Harvard he had become indifferent to the Church” (p. 18).
Then, at twenty-one, Eliot had a spiritual experience while walking in Boston, and wrote an unpublished poem called “Silence.” “This is the ultimate hour,” it reads, when “The seas of experience” become “suddenly still”:
You may say what you will, At such peace I am terrified. There is nothing else beside. (qtd. in Gordon, p. 23)
That same year he moved to Paris to study and write, finishing in 1911 his first major poem, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock,” which gives anguished voice to unsatisfied spiritual hunger.
The speaker of “Prufrock” suffers on a metaphysical rack, torn between the numbing monotony of civilized life on the one hand, and his Augustinian restlessness, his desire for transcendence, on the other. The poem opens with an image of a deadening anesthetic: “the evening is spread out against the sky / Like a patient etherised upon a table.” But the speaker wanders “half-deserted streets” that seem to “lead you to an overwhelming question.” He fears to name that question, preferring distraction instead: “Oh, do not ask, ‘What is it?’ / Let us go and make our visit.” Yet the social rounds, comforts, and pleasures of elite society fail to satisfy. And the “question” still troubles him, though he remains paralyzed. With repetition that dramatizes this paralysis, Prufrock wonders, “‘Do I dare?’ and ‘Do I dare?’” And again, “Do I dare / Disturb the universe?”
In Prufrock, we hear a twentieth-century echo of that weary voice of Ecclesiastes:2
For I have known them all already, known them all—Have known the evenings, mornings, afternoons,I have measured out my life with coffee spoons. . . .
Yet he sees in himself and in others the gnawing restlessness of the human heart, for we feel some unhappiness that nothing on earth can address:
Shall I say, I have gone at dusk through narrow streetsAnd watched the smoke that rises from the pipesOf lonely men in shirt-sleeves, leaning out of windows? . . .
The routine of the world tries to numb that unhappiness, sapping our desire: “Should I, after tea and cakes and ices, / Have the strength to force the moment to its crisis?” Prufrock admits that “though I have wept and fasted, wept and prayed,” he may lack the strength to pursue the question: “I have seen the moment of my greatness flicker,” he says, “And in short, I was afraid.”
But he recalls a memory of witnessing something beyond this world. It takes place at sea. Eliot’s Prufrock recalls: “I have heard the mermaids singing, each to each.” Yet he worries that they will not “sing to me.” In sublime sea imagery, he recalls:
I have seen them riding seaward on the wavesCombing the white hair of the waves blown backWhen the wind blows the water white and black.
Only in his dreams has he been able to taste this unknown world represented by the ocean, in a moment of peace and stillness:
We have lingered in the chambers of the seaBy sea-girls wreathed with seaweed red and brownTill human voices wake us, and we drown.
To live life without the transcendent means death. The poem ends without resolution; we do not learn what Prufrock will do.
With the help of the American poet and critic Ezra Pound, “Prufrock” would be Eliot’s first big break. The two men met in England in 1914, and Pound helped Eliot land the poem in Poetry the next year. For some years, Pound served as an overbearing but helpful mentor, helping Eliot publish his first collection of poems; his heavy editorial hand would chisel Eliot’s The Waste Land into its final form.
In 1915 Eliot also met Vivienne Haigh-Wood. They were married within two months, and seem to have been unhappy from the start. The colorful, theatrical Vivienne had an unstable streak and complex chronic illnesses, a reliance on sedatives that may have caused hallucinations; there was an affair with Bertrand Russell, suicidal spells. Gordon recounts that Eliot “responsibly” took care of Vivienne (p. 128); but he retreated into himself.
It is striking that during these disastrous early years of marriage, and in the midst of a World War, Eliot achieved so much. His first book of poems, Prufrock and Other Observations appeared in 1917; in 1919 the Woolfs published a collection of his poems in their private press. He took a good job at Lloyds Bank. And by 1919, he was planning The Waste Land.
He drafted much of it after a psychological breakdown in 1921, brought on most certainly by the stress of his marriage. At Margate on the English seaside, and in Switzerland at Lausanne, Eliot recuperated, rested, and wrote. It would be his most famous poem, but one that has continued to defeat readers with its fragmented form and its collage of allusions and quotations in foreign languages.
The poem captures a modern Europe (the Waste Land) utterly hostile to high or human things. Eliot depicts people more dead than alive, who inhabit deserts or polluted urban spaces, eat food from tins, work mechanically at their jobs, copulate, compete, and distract themselves from their pain. The Waste Land has a profound ugliness, infertile, hellish, and frustrated.
Some critics understood it as a poem of despair and disillusionment. And indeed Eliot wrote it at a low point in his life. But Gordon correctly perceives in the poem the “possibility of regeneration” (p. 186). For Gordon, Eliot’s experience of the bad news served to prepare him for Christianity: “For him to experience the world as a waste was a prerequisite to experiencing it in faith” (p. 153). It would represent a step along the poet’s winding path to Christ.
“April is the cruellest month,” Eliot’s speaker begins. It is cruel because it stirs up new life, “breeding / Lilacs” and “mixing / Memory and desire….” The people in the Waste Land prefer hibernation, a kind of death-in-life:
Winter kept us warm, covering Earth in forgetful snow, feeding A little life with dried tubers.
The Waste Land is a barren desert, lacking water, that essential ingredient for all life:
…where the sun beats And the dead tree gives no shelter, the cricket no relief, And the dry stone no sound of water.
But for Eliot, the drought has a spiritual cause. We might recall the biblical drought of 1 Kings during the reign of the idolatrous Ahab. But the closer source may be Augustine, who writes in his Confessions: “I sank away from Thee, and I wandered, O my God, too much astray from Thee my stay, in these days of my youth, and I became to myself a barren land.”3 It was not always so. Eliot’s speaker recalls in the first section a memory of beauty, love, fertility:
‘You gave me hyacinths first a year ago;‘They called me the hyacinth girl.’—Yet when we came back, late, from the hyacinth garden,Your arms full, and your hair wet, I could notSpeak, and my eyes failed, I was neitherLiving nor dead, and I knew nothing,Looking into the heart of light, the silence.
Eliot, not yet a Christian, adapts prelapsarian Genesis: we have a man and a woman in a garden. And we have that mystical term from the title of his 1910 poem, “silence.” The poem will ruminate on this single question: how can water—therefore life and fertility—be restored to the Waste Land?
This memory of Edenic harmony between man and woman stands in searing contrast to the relations between the sexes in The Waste Land. Section II opens with a wealthy couple in luxury: “The Chair she sat in, like a burnished throne, / Glowed on the marble.” We see “The glitter of her jewels” a candelabra, and an ornate ceiling called a “laquearia.” But right away the scene bodes ill for the couple. The lines about the throne have been adapted from Shakespeare’s Antony and Cleopatra, and Eliot borrowed “laquearia” from the Latin of Book I of Virgil’s Aeneid, where the doomed queen Dido falls for Aeneas at a rich Carthaginian feast. Both romances end in disaster, and both women will die by suicide. The scene in Eliot’s poem has no love: the wife’s hysterical speech punctures the silence, while the husband retreats into his own thoughts without responding. Here Eliot’s own unhappy marriage informs the poem:
‘My nerves are bad to-night. Yes, bad. Stay with me.‘Speak to me. Why do you never speak. Speak.
The lines echo Vivienne Eliot’s voice: Gordon records that she had a repetitive manner of speaking.
Section III reiterates the human dysfunction at the heart of the Waste Land with a sexual encounter between another couple, a typist and a “young man carbuncular.” The scene takes place “At the violet hour,” a time “when the human engine waits / Like a taxi….” Here Eliot’s simile signals that what follows will be mechanical, an interaction in which humans—especially women—become objects of mere utility. The young woman “lays out food in tins” for the young man with infected boils.
The time is now propitious, as he guesses,The meal is ended, she is bored and tired,Endeavours to engage her in caressesWhich still are unreproved, if undesired.Flushed and decided, he assaults at once;Exploring hands encounter no defence;His vanity requires no response,And makes a welcome of indifference.
We note the absence of desire in the woman, yet her mute resignation; we note the violence in Eliot’s word “assaults.” When the man leaves, the woman “smooths her hair with automatic hand, / And puts a record on the gramophone.” In the Waste Land, media fills the emptiness of our lives.
As the section closes, Eliot alludes again to Augustine, from Book II of the Confessions: “To Carthage then I came.” Augustine had written of Carthage as a place “where there sang all around me in my ears a cauldron of unholy loves.”4 Like Virgil’s Aeneas, Augustine must leave Carthage and go to Italy; yet unlike Aeneas, Augustine finds not war and empire but conversion and baptism.
Indeed, baptism lurks behind much of Eliot’s The Waste Land, with its desert images, depravity, and yearning for water. Like Prufrock, the dwellers in the Waste Land fear to take the plunge into the deeper life; they fear the cost. The tarot-reader Madame Sosostris, in the poem’s first section, warned the speaker to “Fear death by water.” But that will be the only way to renewal: some ritual, some sacrifice, must occur if the land is to be restored. Rebirth requires death: Eliot titles the poem’s next section “Death by Water.”
The section depicts a drowned sailor in unexpected peace. Phlebas the Phoenician floats and sinks quietly in the sea, away from the world of “profit and loss.” There is a gentleness even to his silent decomposition: “A current under sea / Picked his bones in whispers.” “Gentile or Jew,” the speaker addresses the reader, which may allude to 1 Corinthians 12:13: “For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body, whether we be Jews or Gentiles….” We die ritually in baptism, purified and reborn into new life.
Section V is an apocalypse, shot through with religious images of death and resurrection, and we dimly glimpse the Christ:
After the torchlight red on sweaty facesAfter the frosty silence in the gardensAfter the agony in stony placesThe shouting and the cryingPrison and palace and reverberation
The images remind us of the Passion of Jesus; it is as if we stand suspended between the moment of His death and the Resurrection: “He who was living is now dead….” But we hear the “thunder of spring over distant mountains.” The rain has not yet come to the Waste Land, but a sacrifice has been effected. The yearning for water now intensifies: “If there were water,” the speaker says, “If there were the sound of water only…” “But there is no water….” Yet the world of the poem gives signs that something has changed. Eliot evokes Luke 24, where two disciples meet—but initially fail to recognize—the resurrected Jesus on the road to Emmaus:
Who is the third who walks always beside you?When I count, there are only you and I togetherBut when I look ahead up the white roadThere is always another one walking beside youGliding wrapt in a brown mantle, hooded….
This sacrifice has brought the apocalypse:
Falling towersJerusalem Athens AlexandriaVienna London
The death of Jesus did the same: the sky growing dark and the tearing of the temple veil—a literal apocalypse (from the Greek for “to uncover”). But it is not the end, for we hear “voices singing out of empty cisterns and exhausted wells.” A reference to Jeremiah 38, certainly—the prophet held in an empty cistern—but perhaps also to a strange moment in the Gospel of Matthew 27:52–53: after the death of Jesus we learn that the dead began to come back to life and emerge from their graves.
We get “a flash of lightning. Then a damp gust / Bringing rain….” We can smell the coming rain, promising cleansing and fertility to the Waste Land, but it has not yet fallen. Instead, the thunder preceding the storm delivers a sermon, a law offering an antidote to the infernal life of spiritual barrenness. Drawing on a fable in the Upanishads, Eliot delivers commands from the heavens: “Datta,” “Dayadhvam,” and “Damyata”: give, have compassion, have self-control. Only then will peace be found, and the poem ends with a Vedic mantra, used at the conclusion of rituals, to invoke peace: “Shantih shantih shantih.” Here Eliot’s typographical choice to add extra space imparts a slow solemnity, a ritual blessing over the frenetic and vulgar world. We hear in this poem that deep human longing for peace. And Eliot’s footnote suggests the universality of this desire: he translates the Hindu blessing by adapting the words of St. Paul to the Philippians: “The Peace which passeth understanding.”
The Waste Land is a fundamentally modern poetic quest for wholeness; it seeks a ritual and a law that will put to death the barrenness of selfishness, bring about the end while making a new beginning. As one of the three kings from Eliot’s post-conversion “Journey of the Magi” says, recalling what he found at the birth of Christ: “I had seen birth and death, / But had thought they were different….”
The years after The Waste Land mark another low point in Eliot’s life. Gordon recounts that the poet’s already-collapsing marriage now entered into severe crisis: Eliot’s friends found him “on the verge of a breakdown” and “in a state of collapse” (p. 203). Sometimes he relied on whiskey. In 1924–25 Vivienne had nearly died of a mysterious illness, and she would grow increasingly erratic into the 1930s. In 1925 he was already thinking of separation. Out of this era springs the dark poem, “The Hollow Men” (1925). “This is the dead land,” the speaker says, barren and idolatrous:
This is the cactus landHere the stone imagesAre raised, here they receivedThe supplication of a dead man’s hand
Like the world of The Waste Land, it is a desert. But unlike that earlier poem or even the spiritual yearnings of “Prufrock,” in “The Hollow Men” there emerges a dim vision of eternity, “Of death’s twilight kingdom,” where mysterious “eyes” and a “Multifoliate rose” dwell. These images come from Dante’s Divine Comedy, the eyes of Beatrice and the saints in Paradiso grouped into the shape of a huge heavenly rose.5 The speaker even attempts to pray, uttering incomplete lines from the end of the Lord’s Prayer:
For Thine isLife isFor Thine is the
“Eliot was honest about failure,” Gordon writes: “lips that would—but can’t quite—pray…” (p. 237). “Well before his conversion,” she continues, “Eliot foresaw the difficulties: the process of transformation might be painful and protracted, possibly, through the rest of his life” (p. 238). But he was moving. He had also read the seventeenth-century Anglican divine Lancelot Andrewes, and would find himself drawn to Anglo-Catholicism with its emphasis on sacraments, liturgy, and prayer. In 1926 Eliot began attending communion services. And on June 29th of 1927 he received baptism—a death by water indeed. The next day he was confirmed, and in 1928 he began making regular confession. Out of this conversion would eventually spring Eliot’s great Christian poetry, culminating in The Four Quartets.
But Eliot’s real conversion, and his sincere devotional and sacramental life, coexist with his equally real weakness, wounds, and failures. Gordon has revised and updated her biography to include new insights gained from a cache of eleven hundred private letters that were sealed to scholars until 2019. They are letters Eliot wrote to a woman named Emily Hale, with whom he carried on a long, celibate but emotionally-intimate affair, while still married to his first wife. 1927 had rekindled their friendship, and it soon became something more; she dined with Eliot and his wife in 1930, when she was staying in England; he visited her in America while he held his 1932 Norton professorship at Harvard. Eliot gave Hale a ring, and over the years would write more letters to her than he did to any other correspondent in his life. In 1933 he wrote his lawyer to request legal separation from Vivienne, but she refused. Returning to England, he hid from his increasingly unstable wife as she pursued him from place to place in London. In 1934, Hale took a year’s leave from teaching to live in England, taking long walks with Eliot in the countryside, and sometime in 1935, they visited the old estate of Burnt Norton together in a trip that likely inspired the first poem of Eliot’s greatest work, The Four Quartets.
If a quartet has four instruments, The Four Quartets can be understood as a concert of the four elements of earth, air, wind, and fire.6 These elements, regarded by the ancients as composing all matter, appear repeatedly throughout the poems. The now-Anglican Eliot’s vision is firmly sacramental. Humans find ourselves inextricably, even tragically material: caught up in the cycles, seasons, and movements of the physical world, our bodies and buildings eroded by the passage of time. Yet the path to God lies not in escaping matter or transcending our fragile limitations. Rather, Eliot’s poems dramatize patience, endurance, humble acceptance of our finitude, our failure. It is a purgatorial labor, but we do not go unassisted. For in certain moments, Eternity actually pierces into the material world to reveal itself.
“Burnt Norton,” the first poem of The Four Quartets, opens in that archetypal space of a garden. Although it is a real English garden it is also “our first world,” an abandoned Eden after the fall. There is an “empty alley” and a “drained pool. / Dry the pool, dry concrete, brown edged….” Then suddenly the speaker sees a vision, a moment of revelation nested in everyday things. As he looks,
…the pool was filled with water out of sunlight,And the lotos rose, quietly, quietly,The surface glittered out of heart of light….
It is the same kind of divine moment that haunted the speaker of The Waste Land—a memory of a time in a garden, where he stood “Looking into the heart of light, the silence.” But this vision in “Burnt Norton” vanishes: “Then a cloud passed, and the pool was empty.” A bird admonishes the speaker and his unnamed companion to “go,” for “human kind / Cannot bear very much reality.” They have had a brief encounter, in time, with the Eternal:
At the still point of the turning world. Neither flesh nor fleshless;Neither from nor towards; at the still point, there the dance is….
The speaker muses on this mysterious state,
I can only say, there we have been: but I cannot say where.And I cannot say, how long, for that is to place it in time.
In it we have a taste of heavenly rest:
The inner freedom from the practical desire,The release from action and suffering, release from the innerAnd the outer compulsion, yet surroundedBy a grace of sense, a white light still and moving…
Although timeless, it is necessarily brief for those of us in time. Like the myth of Semele, or Moses on the mountaintop in Exodus 33, humans are not ready for a direct or sustained encounter with Infinitude or Omnipotence. We are protected from eternity precisely by our material bodies and our time-bound state:
Yet the enchainment of past and futureWoven in the weakness of the changing body,Protects mankind form heaven and damnationWhich flesh cannot endure.
So it comes in glimpses only, flickers of spiritual consolation and divine presence:
…the moment in the rose-garden,The moment in the arbour where the rain beat,The moment in the draughty church at smokefall….
Perhaps in art, the poet Eliot proposes, we can try to approach or capture this timeless state. Yet poetry too suffers from limits and decay:
…Words strain,Crack and sometimes break, under the burden,Under the tension, slip, slide, perish,Decay with imprecision, will not stay in place,Will not stay still….
For Eliot, these human words point to Christ, “The Word in the desert.” Christ The Word represents the cosmic point of contact—indeed marriage—between “the still point” of the Deity and the material world: the Incarnation of God as flesh.
Yet even Christ suffered and died, subjecting Himself to the limits of our always-decaying elemental world. Call it kenosis or ascesis, but it lies at the heart of The Four Quartets. One of the epigraphs comes from a fragment of the Greek presocratic philosopher Heraclitus: “The way up and the way down is one and the same.”7 Ascent to heaven, in Eliot’s Christian vision, requires descent into the grave. We should also recall Dante here. In Canto I of Inferno, the pilgrim tries to ascend up a hill towards heaven, but finds himself driven back by the wild beasts that represent his sins. Rescued by the poet Virgil, he is dismayed to learn that the only way forward is down through the caverns of hell. What follows is a journey towards Paradiso; but the way up requires descent first, into darkness and death, into human brokenness and need.
“East Coker,” the second poem of The Four Quartets, doubles down and dwells upon our mortality, upon just how subject to decay we are. Yet as the poem reveals, because of the Incarnation, this curse has been transformed into our salvation.
Houses rise and fall, crumble, are extended,Are removed, destroyed, restored, or in their placeIs an open field, or a factory, or a by-pass.Old stone to new building, old timber to new fires,Old fires to ashes, and ashes to the earthWhich is already flesh, fur, and faeces,Bone of man and beast, cornstalk and leaf.
Even the best human things will decompose. The speaker sees a vision of early modern inhabitants dancing a traditional folk dance, but their “heavy feet in clumsy shoes” are “Earth feet, loam feet.” Here Eliot’s ambiguity allows two readings: the shoes may be caked with earth and loam, but his wording also suggests the feet themselves are made of earth, made of loam. In the opening of the poem we have been reminded that earth comes from dead things, “is already flesh, fur and faeces, / Bone of man and beast.” The solemn dancers have death clinging to their shoes; and their flesh and bones are, in both a Biblical and a chemical sense, made of the elements of the earth. “Dung and death,” the poem reiterates. Everything dies: “The dancers are all gone under the hill,” the poem laments, “O dark dark dark. They all go into the dark”:
And we all go with them, into the silent funeral,Nobody’s funeral, for there is no one to bury.
But if Dylan Thomas counselled “rage against the dying of the light,” Eliot’s poem rejects that rebellion. He understands that the process of aging and dying is precisely our ascetical—even purgatorial—path to God. The proper response to our finitude is acceptance, the poem proposes, “the wisdom of humility.” For the way up and the way down is one and the same. “I said to my soul, be still, and let the dark come upon you / Which shall be the darkness of God.” In this Eliot follows one of his models, the poet St. John of the Cross, whose “dark night” becomes the site of encounter with the Divine. Echoing the words of the Spanish mystic’s treatise, Ascent of Mount Carmel, Eliot’s poem declares a via negativa:8
In order to arrive at what you do not knowYou must go by a way which is the way of ignorance.In order to possess what you do not possessYou must go by the way of dispossession.In order to arrive at what you are notYou must go through the way in which you are not.
Eliot uses the metaphor of surgery to depict this negative way, this death-to-self. Someone must operate with “steel” on “the distempered part” of our soul. It is a painful image, but we can take consolation because the physician Himself, Christ, knows pain and death intimately. Eliot calls Him “The wounded surgeon,” with “bleeding hands,” Who uses our suffering, failures, our aging and dying, to heal us: for “to be restored, our sickness must grow worse.” In fact, we can only be sustained by the ultimate sacrament of suffering and death:
The dripping blood our only drink,The bloody flesh our only food….
Yet self-emptying and death do not mean passive quietism. Eliot imagines an adventure, a heroic endurance of living that remains active in seeking God. “Old men ought to be explorers,” he writes, and seek
…a further union, a deeper communionThrough the dark cold and the empty desolation,The wave cry, the wind cry, the vast watersOf the petrel and the porpoise.
There is the sea again, just as we found it in “Prufrock.” The third of The Four Quartets, “The Dry Salvages” develops this sea journey, and Eliot uses it as an image of the course of human life. On the one hand, the sea represents our passage through cosmic time; the poem introduces a bell buoy which tolls not by the clock but as the water moves it:
The tolling bellMeasures time not our time, rung by the unhurriedGround swell….
On the other hand, the destructive action of the sea also represents the ongoing breakdown of our material bodies:
It tosses up our losses, the torn seine,The shattered lobsterpot, the broken oarAnd the gear of foreign dead men.
“Where is there an end of it,” the poem laments, giving voice to our universal anguish:
Where is there an end to the drifting wreckage,The prayer of the bone on the beach, the unprayablePrayer at the calamitous annunciation?
Calamitous annunciation. Eliot coins a great phrase for those irrevocable events that shatter our best-laid plans: the fatal accident, the suicide, the air raid, the cancer diagnosis or the end of a marriage. In words pregnant with autobiography, Eliot describes our “Years of living among the breakage,” all the ruins left by time, sin, decay. And at the end of our sea journey we find only what looks like failure: “In a drifting boat with a slow leakage,” as we hear “the undeniable / Clamour of the bell of the last annunciation,” that final calamitous announcement of our own death. Yet he shows us precisely where our hope lies, and what our response can be, in this mess, this ruin of postlapsarian life. The speaker repeats the earlier lines with some crucial changes: although “There is no end of it,” this “drift of the sea and the drifting wreckage,” we have “the hardly, barely prayable / Prayer of the one Annunciation.” Eliot’s capitalization reminds us of Mary’s response to the calamitous moment when an angel delivered the news of God’s proposal. It changed the entire trajectory of her virgin life, yet her response is “be it unto me according to thy word” (Luke 1:38).
This is the heroic sea adventure, the journey to the Utter East at the end of our life, with the Virgin’s words on our lips, that God’s will be done to us. So the poem stirs us to “Fare forward” out to sea, “Not fare well, / But fare forward, voyagers.” Now the funereal sound of that tolling bell buoy becomes “the sea bell’s / Perpetual angelus,” a prayer recalling the Annunciation, and which includes the words of Mary’s fiat. God’s will, no matter what it may be.
To sustain us on our sea journey towards death and dissolution come those fleeting experiences of transcendence, beauty, or love, like the vision in the rose garden of “Burnt Norton.” The poem recalls “the moment in and out of time”:
The wild thyme unseen, or the winter lightningOr the waterfall, or music heard so deeplyThat it is not heard at all….
But these moments
…are only hints and guesses,Hints followed by guesses; and the restIs prayer, observance, discipline, thought and action.
Sustained by those visions or moments of spiritual consolation, we must humbly persevere: “only undefeated / Because we have gone on trying.”
The last of The Four Quartets, “Little Gidding,” begins with words and images that take us back to the garden in “Burnt Norton.” Although occurring in a different season and a different region of England, the poem signals that we have returned. It opens in “Midwinter spring,” a paradoxical moment of sun and melt in the dead of winter. “A muted longing for renewal breathes through the opening of the last Quartet,” writes Gordon, and she imagines that Eliot “wondered if the divine fire that seemed so remote would ever quicken him” (p. 364).
Like that earlier vision of the lotos in the pool in Burnt Norton, it is a timeless moment: “Sempiternal” and “Suspended in time.” It points to greater light and warmth, which leaves us longing for “the summer, the unimaginable / Zero summer.” Zero summer, an absolute zero that remains warm and full of life, yet like matter at absolute zero, entropy and atomic motion become nearly stilled. We are back at “the still point of the turning world.” Little Gidding was a seventeenth-century religious lay community founded by the Anglican clergyman Nicholas Ferrar, a humble place with a “dull façade.” “There are other places,” the speaker muses,
Which also are the world’s end, some at the sea jaws,Or over a dark lake, in a desert or a city—But this is the nearest, in place and time,Now and in England.
Now and in England. Here Eliot’s poem reveals that Eternity (“the world’s end”) is not something that requires far journeys or colossal striving to find: as an Anglican receiving the sacrament, Eliot knew that God is available to us here and now. This place of contact with God is not a place to be understood or analyzed:
…You are not here to verify,Instruct yourself, or inform curiosityOr carry report. You are here to kneelWhere prayer has been valid.
But prayer and the timeless moment do not stop our dissolution, the erosion of everything by time and disaster and sin. Far from it:
Water and fire shall rotThe marred foundations we forgot,Of sanctuary and choir.
Eliot knew this fact from personal experience: the poem appeared in 1942, after so many English churches had been destroyed by German bombs.9
Indeed, the war shaped the poem substantially. At the heart of “Little Gidding,” Eliot transforms a wartime scene, city streets after an air raid, into an encounter with the next world.
In the uncertain hour before the morningNear the ending of interminable nightAt the recurrent end of the unendingAfter the dark dove with the flickering tongue[10]Had passed below the horizon of his homingWhile the dead leaves still rattled on like tinOver the asphalt where no other sound wasBetween three districts whence the smoke arose….
In this bombed-out modern London, the speaker finds the ghost of his “dead master.” There are echoes of Dante, who in Inferno meets his literary model Virgil and his damned mentor Brunetto Latini. But the point is simply that the speaker, a version of Eliot himself, encounters some great writer from the tradition.
Yet as the two artists meet “at this intersection time,” as “We trod the pavement in a dead patrol,” what follows is a stunning renunciation. Rather than talking shop about writing or literature or tradition, the master dismisses it all:
…I am not eager to rehearseMy thought and theory which you have forgotten.These things have served their purpose: let them be.
Instead, what the master offers is to “disclose the gifts reserved for age / To set a crown upon your lifetime’s effort.” He gives a brutal list: age gradually steals our capacity for pleasures, “the cold friction of expiring sense” while “body and soul begin to fall asunder.” We gain a painful awareness of “human folly,” and finally, of the failures of our own lives:
…the rending pain of re-enactmentOf all that you have done, and been; the shameOf motives late revealed, and the awarenessOf things ill done and done to others’ harmWhich once you took for exercise of virtue.
It will be an excruciating self-revelation of our residual selfishness, the impure motives tainting our best deeds: this is why all of us must be “restored by that refining fire.” This is the purgatorial process in this life and the next, the stripping away of all that we most sought and valued, “detachment / From self and from things and from persons….”
What brings this refining fire? Here Eliot’s poem makes an astonishing turn by conflating two images. The earlier German bomber plane attacking London was “the dark dove with the flickering tongue,” but now it returns: “The dove descending breaks the air / With flame of incandescent terror.” Now the dove, the Biblical symbol and manifestation of the Holy Spirit, brings this fire, which is “The one discharge from sin and error”:
The only hope, or else despairLies in the choice of pyre or pyre—To be redeemed from fire by fire.
God’s Providence, Eliot shows, can turn even the horror of the Blitz into a refiner’s fire that will save us from the fires of hell. This saving fire becomes our “torment,” and an “intolerable shirt of flame,” like the poisoned robe that tortured the hero Heracles; yet the myth of Heracles illuminates Eliot’s Christian theology. When Heracles died, the funeral pyre which ended his torture became his apotheosis, and he was taken to heaven as a god. So the fire of God, present to us even in our severest earthly sufferings, burns away our mortal dross and unites us with Himself.
The pilgrim Dante must likewise pass through a wall of fire at the end of his journey through Purgatory. Only then can he enter the Garden of Eden again, that original home from which our sin expelled us. So too Eliot’s poem concludes that
…the end of all our exploringWill be to arrive where we startedAnd know the place for the first time.Through the unknown, remembered gateWhen the last of earth left to discoverIs that which was the beginning.
God’s refining fire strips us to “A condition of complete simplicity / (Costing not less than everything),” Eliot writes. And quoting the revelation of God to Julian of Norwich, the poem reaches its end: “And all shall be well and / All manner of thing shall be well.” For “the tongues of flame” brought by the terrible trials of earthly life—and by the permissive will of the Holy Spirit—become a “crowned knot of fire,” and that pain, Pentecostal, purgatorial, purifying suffering, becomes the rose in Dante’s paradise: “the fire and the rose are one.”
The Four Quartets was Eliot’s last major poem, and one of the great Christian poems of all time. As one of my professors in college told me simply: “These are poems to be prayed, not read.” And so I must admit that learning about the failures of Eliot’s life was a somewhat depressing experience. The Four Quartets come into being in the midst of Eliot’s romance with Emily Hale. In 1938, his first wife Vivienne was committed to an asylum, after she was found wandering the streets at night, alone, paranoid, and confused. Eliot had spoken openly to Hale about marrying her, but his High Anglican commitments would not permit him to divorce and remarry while his first wife still lived, so Emily waited. When Vivienne died in 1947, the moment seemed to have come. But Eliot called it off forever. There was another less intimate but extremely close friendship with an English woman named Mary Trevelyan, who was also in love with the poet and hoped to marry him. Then in 1957 Eliot, now a Nobel Prize winner and a successful publisher at Faber & Faber, shocked everyone who knew him by secretly marrying his secretary Valerie Fletcher, thirty-eight years his junior. By all accounts, they were blissfully happy until the poet died in 1965.
Gordon’s well-researched and clearly-written biography remains sympathetic to Eliot, even while shedding light on the dysfunctions that plagued him; it never becomes a cancel-job or a #MeToo exposé. Gordon ultimately sees the poet as pointing us to sanctity, while never overcoming the wounds that held him back. “Denied perfection,” she writes, “he lived to perpetuate its possibility for other lives” (p. 529). Yet I wonder if her emphasis on the failure of Eliot’s spiritual quest comes from a misunderstanding of the key fact of Christianity. Gordon describes Eliot’s lifelong attempt “to recover the divine” (p. 364). And perhaps Eliot did at times believe that Christianity was man’s search for God. But in his poetry, as in the Sacred Scriptures, it is quite the other way around. Man does not attain God by striving for perfection: God rescues man by coming to find us in our most broken places.
We see this clearly in The Four Quartets; each of the poems has ruins: the estate of Burnt Norton received its name because its owner went mad and burnt himself and the house; the poem “East Coker” opens with a description of buildings falling into ruin; the rocks known as The Dry Salvages, off the shore of Rockport, MA, have wrecked numerous ships; and Eliot links Little Gidding, with its chapel once ransacked by Cromwell’s soldiers, to a scene of a bombed-out London. Each of these ruined scenes becomes a place where Heaven reveals itself to man: the lotos flower and the “heart of light” of “Burnt Norton,” the mystical “darkness of God” in “East Coker,” the “Perpetual angelus” of the bell-buoy in “The Dry Salvages,” and “The dove descending” upon the London Blitz of “Little Gidding.” In each of these, human wreckage becomes the place where God appears to us.
If we look to the Gospel accounts, we find the same thing: the Incarnation comes to an Israel dominated by pagans and ruled by corrupt religious leaders; Jesus arrives at the tax collector Matthew’s custom house; He meets the hideous Gadarene demoniacs among the tombs; He goes to the grave of the decomposing Lazarus; the father of the Prodigal Son runs to meet his disgraced child. And we need look no further than the Cross, the contact point, the intersection between Man’s worst brokenness and God’s greatest deed. The wounds of Jesus shockingly reveal the fragility of our bodies and the cruelty of which we are capable; yet this is the privileged place of encounter between man and God, a scandalous historical moment of evil, brokenness, and death which is God’s definitive revelation of His love. Jesus is Eliot’s “wounded surgeon,” the God Who heals us by meeting us at our deepest sin, our worst wounds. God does not stand aloof, waiting for us to attain perfection; as Eliot’s best poems reveal, God appears suddenly in the ruins, “among the breakage” of our profoundly imperfect lives.
Notes
- ↩
Lyndall Gordon, T.S. Eliot: An Imperfect Life (Norton, 2026), ix.
- ↩
Ecclesiastes 1:14: “I have seen all the works that are done under the sun; and, behold, all is vanity and vexation of spirit.” Emphasis added.
- ↩
Augustine, Confessions, trans. E.B. Pusey (J.M. Dent & Sons, 1907; repr., Everyman’s Library, 1957), 31.
- ↩
Augustine, Confessions, 32.
- ↩
See for instance Purgatorio 27.52–54, 31.109, 31.115–117 and Paradiso 31.1–3.
- ↩
This insight comes from a lovely little book by the late Thomas Howard, offering a close reading of Eliot’s Four Quartets. See Thomas Howard, Dove Descending: A Journey into T.S. Eliot’s Four Quartets (Ignatius, 2006), 19.
- ↩
Heraclitus, Source Book in Ancient Philosophy, trans. Charles M. Bakewell (Scribner, 1907), quoted in Christopher Ricks and Jim McCue, eds., The Poems of T.S. Eliot, vol. 1, Collected and Uncollected Poems (Johns Hopkins University Press, 2015), 906.
- ↩
Ricks and McCue, The Poems of T.S. Eliot, 1:945.
- ↩
Gordon also explains that Little Gidding itself suffered from water and fire damage in 1646, when Cromwell’s soldiers attacked the chapel because the community had sheltered King Charles I. She writes: “They ripped out the organ and the pulpit, which they burnt outside, and threw the font, lectern, and engravings into a nearby pond” (p. 366).
[10] Howard, Dove Descending, 130. Howard links the dark dove with a German plane. Ricks and McCue concur. See Ricks and McCue, The Poems of T.S. Eliot, 1:1007.
