There is no such thing as a nonintellectual spirituality. I begin this inaugural Intellectus editorial with this bold statement. A statement that is also, I believe, true. And necessarily so.
Our spirit is the human soul, the principle of life that animates the human person. And the human soul is a rational soul. Of course, the claim that there is no such thing as a nonintellectual spirituality is not contingent upon individual levels of proficiency in matters discursive, argumentative, or demonstrative. Whether one be a philosophical prodigy or not changes nothing about the fundamental orientation of the human person as spiritual and intellectual.
Because the human person is inherently spiritual as well as intellectual (and also religious, I might add—but that’s a matter for another time), it also follows that questions are preeminently important for the spirituality of human persons. It is through questions that the activity of our mind—and therefore our spirituality—is shaped, oriented, and directed. Questions are the instrument through which human persons rationally engage reality. Here we can think of young children moving about nature and pointing to different things that they perceive for the first time and asking their parents, “What is that?” Questions also touch upon who the human person is in himself or herself. What does it mean to be human? What does the good, flourishing, excellent human life look like? Is magnanimity something that can actually be achieved? Questioners seek to know—to reach, to grasp—even the angels. Even God. It is through questions that the spirit of the human person discovers and explores the contours of reality. And it is through questions that the human spirit finally achieves a state of rest.
Consequently, spirituality is an activity of our spirit, our soul. And the preeminent faculty of the human soul is the intellect. Questions draw our intellect—and our spirit—to the things questioned. Therefore, questions both reveal and shape our spirituality.
Two Annunciations
Division characterizes modernity. We see this divisive tendency in culture and society as well as in thought and academia—and even within Christian thought and academia. One of the unfortunate consequences of modernity has been the division between classical wisdom and sacred writings. Exegesis has been separated from principles and dogmas. Furthermore, there has been a division between questions pursued under the light of natural reason, questions pursued under the light of divine faith, and answers expressed in the sacred texts of Scripture. Not only has Jerusalem nothing to do with Athens, but the classical and the medieval also have nothing to do with the modern and the contemporary. Such parties may not even speak.
Perhaps, however, if we look at the fundamental and unifying elements that underlie reality—reality both natural and supernatural—we can recognize a profound and fundamental point of coherence shared by things sacred and secular. This unity, of course, exists and perdures because God is the origin of all that is. He is the first cause that instilled the light of reason within the human soul. He imparts the light of faith because of his gift of grace. And he has graciously revealed himself to us through Sacred Tradition, but also and preeminently in the inspired written Word of God.
In my judgment, we can recognize the confluence of these dynamics in a very vivid way at the beginning of the Gospel of St. Luke. Indeed, these dynamics are acutely present within the same chapter of St. Luke’s Gospel—its first chapter. In this passage, we hear about two annunciations. The primary annunciation, of course, is the capital-A Annunciation—that of the Blessed Virgin Mary. There is another annunciation, however—of lesser sublimity but still of momentous importance. And it is the similarities and differences between these two annunciations that inspire further thought and reflection about things perennial and things contemporary.
Zechariah’s annunciation comes first (Luke 1:5–25). The Gospel speaks of a priest named Zechariah, the husband of Elizabeth, and it says, “They were both righteous before God, walking in all the commandments and ordinances of the Lord.” Nonetheless, they suffered. And what did they suffer? An absence. A privation. “They had no child, because Elizabeth was barren, and both were advanced in years.”
During the course of his priestly duties, Zechariah experiences an angelic encounter. And, quite understandably, he is overwhelmed by the experience. Zechariah is “troubled” by this meeting. The angel, however, consoles him: “Do not be afraid, Zechariah, for your prayer is heard, and your wife Elizabeth will bear you a son, and you shall call his name John.” The angel goes on to accentuate the momentous identity and vocation of their son, John the Baptist. John’s story will be one of the most remarkable in all of history—not only in birth but also in life and in legacy. His life and legacy will not only be the cause of natural joy for Zechariah and Elizabeth but will also be forever associated with something supernatural and salvific: “He will be filled with the Holy Spirit, even from his mother’s womb, and he will turn many of the sons of Israel to the Lord their God.”
Zechariah, understandably stupefied before this prospect, says, “How shall I know this? For I am an old man, and my wife is advanced in years.” This is a pivotal moment in the narrative. And what follows this moment stands in sharp contrast to the joy characteristic of the earlier narratival details. The angel identifies himself as none other than Gabriel. Gabriel explains that he stands in the presence of God and that he has not come with this message from his own initiative or by his own authority. Rather, it was God who sent him to bring this “good news”—this gospel—to Zechariah. And yet, all is not well. The angel explains something else beyond the future birth of John the Baptist, something that is to befall Zechariah, his father: “Behold, you will be silent and unable to speak until the day that these things come to pass, because you did not believe my words, which will be fulfilled in their time.” This encounter terminates in a punishment. Mutedness. Zechariah is unable to speak.
The angel Gabriel and the Gospel author waste no time, and immediately following Zechariah’s encounter with Gabriel, we hear of this same angel greeting yet another human person, “a virgin betrothed to a man whose name was Joseph,” and her name, of course, is Mary (Luke 1:26–38). Gabriel greets Mary with one of the most famous salutations in all of history: “Hail, O favored one, the Lord is with you!” St. Luke explains that “she was greatly troubled at the saying, and considered in her mind what sort of greeting this might be.” The angel, however, consoles the young woman and says, “Do not be afraid, Mary, for you have found favor with God. And behold, you will conceive in your womb and bear a son, and you shall call his name Jesus. He will be great, and will be called the Son of the Most High.”
Mary, astonished by the Annunciation message, says to the angel, “How shall this be, since I have no husband?” The angel responds, “The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you; therefore, the child to be born will be called holy, the Son of God.” Gabriel then punctuates his message with one of the truest statements ever uttered: “For with God nothing will be impossible.” This Annunciation narrative closes with Mary’s famous words, “Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word.” And the angel departs from her—leaving her in graced peace and contemplative tranquility.
Two Very Different Results: Contemplation Versus Isolation
Mary rests in graced peace and contemplative tranquility. Not so with Zechariah. He ruminates in muted isolation. Mary becomes not only the Mother of God but, indeed, precisely because she is the Mother of the Incarnate Word, she becomes the mother of all the supernaturally living. Zechariah, for the present moment (his story, of course, is not over), enjoys no communion with others. He is muted. Isolated. In sum, then, these very similar annunciations have very different conclusions.
The stark contrast between these two ending points arouses a question within us. Why the difference? Why is it that Mary and Zechariah end in such different states after their angelic exchanges? The urgency of this question is accentuated when we begin to list the striking parallels comprised by these annunciations. In both cases, it is the same angel, Gabriel, who appears to them. And this same angel brings to them a very similar message. Zechariah’s wife Elizabeth and Mary will both bear a son—in undeniably unusual conditions. Admittedly, the son announced to Mary is of a very different sort than that announced to Zechariah. Nonetheless, as a message of new life, the annunciations are identical.
In response to parallel annunciation messages, their human reactions also appear to be virtually identical. Neither Mary nor Zechariah is indifferent to or unaffected by the angelic apparition. Both are troubled by what Gabriel tells them. Indeed, they react in the same way. They both ask a question—a question reflecting their amazement before the angelic annunciation. And yet, the conclusions of their encounters with the angel are radically different: one positive, the other negative. Therefore, it is most reasonable to ask: How ought we to understand these passages? What accounts for the divergent results of these two—very similar—annunciation encounters?
If we carefully examine the narratives and search for a principle of real distinction, one candidate emerges: the specifically different questions that they ask. Although they both ask questions—and in this questioning, again, they are identical—the specific questions that they ask of the angel are decidedly not identical. Indeed, they are radically different. Mary’s question is, “How shall this be?” Zechariah’s question is, “How shall I know?” And it is upon this inquisitive axis that their respective annunciations pivot, and it is from their essentially different questions that their divergent states follow.
How shall I know? Zechariah’s question is a question about knowledge. The orientation of Zechariah’s question is around Zechariah himself—his own knowledge. His question originates from and terminates in him himself. It prioritizes his own preconceptions and categories of thought. If we were to attempt to contextualize the Zecharian question within the history of Western thought, we could point to its resonance with the philosophical project of the Enlightenment. Zechariah’s question is a question, yes; but it is a question that originates from and terminates in human knowledge. For Zechariah, his inherent cognitive categories are the ultimate principles of adjudication. And it is to these categories that the annunciation message must conform. In other words, Zechariah is open to what the angel communicates, but he can only receive an answer that is proportionate to his cognitive requirements, expectations, and specifications. In some ways, then, Zechariah manifests himself as a precursor to René Descartes—among other Enlightenment thinkers. His quest for knowledge begins with himself and from within himself.
Mary’s question, on the other hand, has a very different point of origination. Her quest for knowledge does not begin with herself. It has a radically different formality. How shall this be? Our Lady asks a question about being—reality. If situated within the history of Western philosophy, her question resonates with the philosophical orientation of classical thought. One might even say that Our Lady shows herself to be Aristotelian in fundamental presupposition and conviction. Mary’s question begins with reality. She is not turned in on herself. She is radically outward directed. Hers is a fundamentally contemplative posture and orientation.
Lest we confuse the point, it is important to recognize that Zechariah is not faulted because he asked a question. Both Mary and Zechariah ask a question. Our Lady is also interested in the way things are. Nonetheless, her question is not a question about knowledge. Rather, hers is a question that seeks knowledge—to know the truth. Her question does not originate from herself as the standard of her knowledge but rather is externally inclined—ordered to things beyond herself. In other words, the Blessed Virgin Mary is operating within and from a realist conception of being and knowledge.
The radical difference between their cognitive orientations explains why Mary’s response, recorded in the Angelus, has resounded throughout history to the present day, while Zechariah is left without words, struck mute. Questions about reality are perennial. Because realist questions terminate in the truth about reality—and reality never suffers extinction—they never reach a point of expiration. They are never irrelevant. In contrast, Zechariah is muted not because of some capricious vindictiveness on the part of God, but rather because mutedness is the inescapable consequence of self-oriented inquiry. One is muted because one has nothing to say. The human soul—the human spirit—is naturally inclined to know the truth about reality. It is inherently outward in orientation. And it is through contact with and conformity to reality that the human mind can know, can encounter, and can discourse. If we begin in ourselves, we will find ourselves trapped in a solipsistic cage. In a paradoxical tragedy, we ourselves will be our own downfall. If, conversely, we start with things outside of ourselves—with reality—all is potentially available to the human spirit. For truth is the conformity of the mind to reality—and our spirit’s delight in the truth is as expansive as reality itself.
Intellectus: Intelligence and Spirituality
To return to the point with which I began this editorial: There is no such thing as a nonintellectual spirituality. Our spirituality is inherently connected to our human spirit, the rational soul. And it is through questions that the activities of the rational soul are directed—and, thus, the shape of our spirituality established. Everyone lives within the spirituality of a question. All of us have a single, overarching, and all-encompassing question that shapes who we are, what we are about, and even where our eternal destiny resides. The question is this: According to which question will we live and move and have our being?
To live according to a “Zecharian spirituality” will ultimately result in a certain mutedness—even for those who are quite intellectual, engaged, and loquacious. A self-oriented intellectualism that reads much, thinks much, and writes much—but in isolation from reality—is paradoxical at best and fundamentally frustrated at worst. The human mind is not the end of the human mind. Man is not to live by ideas, concepts, and narratives alone. They are not the term of human existence. Rather, man lives according to the order of reality established by a wise and loving—a provident—God. And because God has oriented the human person to himself and to the reality he has made, all human persons—and all spiritualities of human flourishing—ultimately find their perfective term in the truth.
Intellectus is a journal devoted to the truth—truth both speculative and practical. Nonetheless, it is not uninterested in thoughts, thinking, or thinkers. Indeed, because human persons are thinking beings who have thoughts, Intellectus is interested in all such matters. The articles published here, however, all arise from a common fundamental orientation: the human desire to know the what, the how, and the why of the things which are. For Intellectus, accordingly, no subject is off the table. And this is so because—with Our Lady and the classical philosophical and theological traditions—Intellectus is consecrated to the dynamics of being and reality. All things are of interest and relevance to those who desire to know the truth.
Intellectus was inspired, in no small part, by what appears to be an ever-growing distance between high-level research and writing, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, the real issues that really matter for real human persons. A kind of stifling academic imperialism has, seemingly, begun to characterize many intellectual publications. Esoteric language and academic apparatus can, at times, seem to reserve authentic expressions of the intellectual life to an elite few. Moreover, and most regrettably, these elite few can also seem to be rather isolated from the fundamental object of all human inquiry, discourse, and spirituality: namely, the truth about reality.
Therefore, Intellectus aspires to provide a forum for inquiry and discourse that is truly high-level—but high-level in substance, not in accidents. This journal seeks to promote serious thought about the things that matter the most in a way that is accessible to all who wish, seriously, to reflect upon reality and to engage in discourse about reality. Ours is not a sectarian project. It seeks to know the way things are, to ask how things should be, and even, at times, to offer practical observations for how things might be—inquiries relevant to all. Our editorial motto and literary ideal is rigor of thought and vigor of prose.
There is no such thing as a nonintellectual spirituality. Consequently, all authentic and perfective spiritualities express the human orientation to the real. Hence, it is our hope that the inquiries found within these pages will promote genuine spirituality through high-level discourse about the things that matter—both naturally and supernaturally. In a word, we wish here to champion the unity of intelligence and spirituality.
Come, then, let us reason together—and so pursue authentic spirituality through thinking that matters.
