A Protestant Look at Trads
This choice to attend the TLM based on personal preferences such as demographic similarity or aesthetics reveals a fundamentally Protestant approach to religion.
The inflow of people, especially young people and men, into older, more traditional forms of Christianity is a trend that has received a significant amount of attention and media coverage. The New York Times observed that “[Eastern] Orthodox pews are overflowing with converts.”1 These converts are often said to be heavily male. The traditional Latin Mass (TLM) in Roman Catholicism is also growing. This too attracted coverage from the Times, which noted that the TLM, “an ancient form of Catholic worship that Pope Francis has tried to discourage, is instead experiencing a revival in the United States.”2 While evidence is much thinner, there also appears to be some flow of conversions into various Eastern Catholic traditions in the US. There has also been significant growth in the Anglican Church in North America, the evangelical alternative to the Episcopal Church.
The discourse about this phenomenon is out of proportion to the numbers. Eastern Orthodoxy is a very small part of American Christianity. Even if there were actually large growth there, it would still be a very small number.3 Likewise, as we will see, the number of TLM attenders is actually not that large. Still, the phenomenon appears real.
Among the reasons these groups are so visible is that they have very visible, and often vocal, online advocates for their approaches. There is a significant Eastern Orthodox presence online, including influencers like Jonathan Pageau, Paul Kingsnorth, Rod Dreher, and Ancient Faith Radio. The Eastern Orthodox blogger Graham Ambrose noted a number of larger Catholic content creators who are Eastern Catholic.4 The same exists in the Protestant world, with the traditionalist Presbyterian influencer known as “Redeemed Zoomer” having over 720,000 YouTube subscribers as of this writing.
In addition to these relatively mainstream voices, there are also a number of very combative social media figures. In the Orthodox world they are often referred to as “Orthobros.” The TLM world also has its equivalent of the Orthobros known as the “Rad Trads.”
While there is little hard data or research on the topic, social media appears to play a key role in driving conversions into these different faith families in general—think Bishop Robert Barron’s Word on Fire ministry—and into some of the traditionalist forms specifically. We also see people being attracted to the theology and forms of these Christian churches, but without formally joining, or continuing to receive the majority of their formation online even after conversion. The Presbyterian journalist Jake Meador observed, “Even though many seem to feel an impulse to study theological traditions and distinctives more deeply in order to place themselves in a particular tradition, these people are still mostly relating to those traditions in consumeristic and highly online ways.”5
My impression is that alienation is a subtext of the draw to these traditions. It is well known that America has experienced a period of decline in trust in institutions. People are disenchanted with our politics, our universities, our religious institutions. The country has experienced a significant demographic transformation from large-scale immigration. There is significant economic anxiety and uncertainty from inflation, artificial intelligence, and more. America has been whipsawed by rapid cultural change or disruption in areas like the sudden rise of the transgender movement or Black Lives Matter. People are more atomized. Romantic relationships are on the decline and there has been a rise in conflict between the sexes.
Many people are disturbed by these changes or feel adrift. Today’s world has been described as one of “liquid modernity.” The growth of traditionalist or “retro” religion is in part driven by a desire to find solid ground on which to stand. It is notable that Orthodoxy and the TLM give people today the impression of being premodern religious forms. They provide a perceived avenue of retreat from the intolerable conditions of modernity. The simultaneous growth in interest in homesteading or becoming a “trad wife” is very consistent with this cultural desire. It is a recurring theme in American industrial society, one seen previously within many of our lifetimes during the counterculture, with elements like the Back to the Land Movement. A turn to Orthodoxy, in particular, appears to also have a subtext of giving up on the West itself, looking for salvation in the East.
But these observations are impressionistic and somewhat speculative. Apart from newspaper articles that lean heavily into profiles and anecdotes, there has not been much systematic study of this phenomenon. But a new academic book from Oxford University Press is starting to change that. Trads: Latin Mass Catholics in the United States by Stephen Cranney and Stephen Bullivant is a sociological study of the TLM community in America.6
This book looks specifically at mainstream Roman Catholic TLM attenders. Its analysis does not include Eastern Catholic Churches, the Dominican Rite, or similar other pockets of traditionalist liturgy inside the Roman Catholic Church. The schismatic Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), which has a significant following and practices the TLM, is also explicitly excluded.
Trads gives a historical overview of the TLM and its development since Vatican II. It conducts a survey of TLM attenders. And it includes results from structured interviews with select people who attend the TLM, as well as observations from attending TLM services.
Recognizing that precise figures are difficult to come by, and that their own figures are subject to significant uncertainty, the authors estimate that there are 510 TLM Masses per Sunday across 320 sites, with an average attendance of 208. That gives their estimate of about 106,000 people attending TLM Masses on a typical Sunday. The authors say that attendance is their “best guess,” giving a range of “91,000 to 123,000” (p. 63). They conservatively estimate that “500,000” people attend a TLM once or twice per year, though it is unclear if this includes special services like weddings and funerals (p. 63).
This number, though significant, is a minute fraction of the total number of Catholics in the United States. Other traditionalist groups are likely proportionally small. This confirms that the online presence of these groups, and the amount of press accorded to them, is disproportionate to their actual numbers.
TLM attendees are more heavily male than non-TLM attenders at 45 percent versus 29 percent. This is in line with the media coverage around the heavy male representation in these traditionalist movements. However, even among TLM attenders, that still means a church that is majority female. The less skewed gender ratio makes it easier for singles to find a spouse, but still leaves women facing a gap in marriage prospects with shared faith commitments. The authors’ racial and ethnic findings were so caveated with regard to the survey that “the relationship between ‘Tradness’ and race/ethnicity is unclear” (p. 67).
The trads have more children than average, but their average number of children is only 2.6 (2.8 among ages 45+ who have reached completed fertility) (p. 70). That’s above average but not excessively high. They are not the Amish. In fact, it is not even high enough to sustain TLM numbers in light of projected religious attrition rates among children. The authors write, “Perhaps the main takeaway point here is that America’s Trads are not some distinct, separate breed of Catholic in demographic, socioeconomic, or political terms” (p. 88). They are more conservative politically and to some extent in terms of their belief in Catholic Church teaching, but not radically different. The authors do note, however, the presence of people from outside the conservative crowd, such as gay attendees, and even some non-Christian attendees attracted primarily by the aesthetic.
American Roman Catholicism has a surprisingly low share of people who believe the Catholic Church’s official teachings. Scholar of religion Ryan Burge, for example, pointed out that less than half of white, conservative, weekly Mass-attending Catholics believe premarital sex is always wrong.7 The Catholic Church itself recognizes a problem here. In the wake of a Pew Research Center finding that only 31 percent of Catholics believe in the real presence of Christ in communion, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops undertook its National Eucharistic Revival initiative.8
This suggests one appeal of the TLM. Serious Roman Catholics who feel something is missing due to the lack of commitment to Catholic teaching in their regular parish community might seek out a TLM parish to find a community of the more like-minded. Call it the “birds of a feather” effect. The authors found this to be the case for some during their interviews, not only in terms of theological commitment, but also age. They write, “Given that young adult Catholics who want to go ‘all in’ with their Faith are relatively scarce in many parishes, it is not a surprise that they tend to gravitate to places with a higher-than-average share of them” (p. 94). TLM Masses are one of those places. They quote one of their interviewees as saying,
A big part [of what draws me] is because it’s a self-selecting group of highly devout Catholics. As a young adult in a secularizing world, the average Catholic parish church environment is both extremely elderly and extremely lukewarm. Everyone knows that if you want to actually find people, especially young people, practicing the faith, that you either go to the Extraordinary Form [TLM] or you go to the Eastern Rite. (p. 94)
This suggests a desire to find a service with people who are both demographically and theologically similar. The TLM also had positive draws from people seeking beauty—the music was especially noted—reverence, and tradition.
This choice to attend the TLM based on personal preferences such as demographic similarity or aesthetics reveals a fundamentally Protestant approach to religion. The Catholic Church traditionally operated on the geographical parish system, perhaps with national parishes based on language for immigrants. Protestants, particularly in the automobile era, have been more likely to choose churches based on affinity for the pastor or congregants, or stylistic preferences such as music. TLM churches exhibit the same individualist, affinity-based approach to religious belonging that characterizes evangelical Protestantism.
There is an irony here that TLM attendees are pursuing traditionalist Catholic ends using modern Protestant means. We are in part formed through institutions and rituals like liturgy. The TLM itself provides a type of formation that is Catholic. But the very process of picking a church or service of one’s choosing to align with perceived personal needs and preferences catechizes people into a Protestant-inflected relationship with the Church.
The positive draw of the TLM is sometimes accompanied by negative experiences with the Novus Ordo Mass. TLM attendees cite things such as boring homilies or improper additions to the service. One interviewee noted “a Wiccan style broomsticks ceremony” as part of one Mass, for example (p. 92). Again, bad experiences or a progressive disenchantment with one’s church is a classic reason for Protestant church switching. Also, these reported experiences do suggest a certain level of alienation from the mainstream Catholic Church underlying some migration to the TLM.
The idea that people are choosing the TLM to find community with people who are more theologically conservative—that is, committed to believing and practicing Catholic Church teaching—is somewhat undercut by shrewd questions in the authors’ polling. They asked about support for the death penalty, recently declared inadmissible by the Catholic Church. If TLM conservatism were fully about adherence to Catholic Church teachings, one would expect TLM attendees to show higher levels of opposition to capital punishment than non-TLM attendees. But it was the reverse. TLM attendees are more likely to support capital punishment. TLM attendees are also more likely to support cutting federal aid to the poor than Novus Ordo attendees.
This suggests that their conservatism is in part that of the American political variety rather than purely theological and that the community they are seeking is one with those who share a similar cultural or political conservatism as much as religious.
A finding that sheds important light on the broader traditionalist religion world is the authors’ conclusion that “we have no particular reason to suppose that the TLM is disproportionately attractive to converts from other denominations or religions” (p. 178). If it were the TLM that was drawing converts into Catholicism itself, we would expect to see converts heavily represented in TLM communities. The fact that we do not is telling. This suggests that traditional liturgical practices are not a primary driver of conversions for other traditions either, in contrast to impressions one might draw from the coverage of this. The search for a historically grounded religion may well be satisfied for many by the Roman Catholic Church itself, even with the Novus Ordo Mass.
This finding does not necessarily directly translate to other traditionalist forms. Converts to Catholicism can choose either the Novus Ordo or the TLM. Converts into Eastern Orthodoxy, by contrast, always end up in a traditionalist liturgy. But it does indicate that the traditionalist liturgical form may not be the main basis of these conversions.
It is also notable that few of today’s TLM attendees are the contemporary descendants of Catholics who clung to the TLM post–Vatican II. It is not a continuation of a historic TLM community, but a newer rediscovery of an older tradition. TLM attenders are overwhelmingly “converts” from mainstream Catholicism and the Novus Ordo. Theoretically, these could include people who converted to Catholicism via the Novus Ordo, then switched to the TLM, but the authors do not suggest that is actually the case.
In terms of their attitudes towards the Catholic Church, most TLM attendees support Vatican II. It is common for TLM attenders to also attend Novus Ordo Masses. There are not many TLM-only attenders, but again it is not clear if weddings and funerals are counted as Novus Ordo Masses here. A full 95 percent of TLM attendees affirm that the Pope is the Vicar of Christ. They had some ambivalent feelings about Pope Francis, with the authors noting “Few interviewees had an unambiguously positive attitude towards Pope Francis” (p. 114). Early indications are that they are more positive toward Pope Leo XIV, however.
The lead author, Cranney, is a member of the LDS Church, and co-author Bullivant is a British Catholic. This is an academic book. But one might ask what the “political” implications of this book’s findings are within the debate over the TLM within Roman Catholicism. Pope John Paul II had given the TLM some recognition. Pope Benedict XVI expanded its legitimate use. However, Pope Francis was something of a critic. He said that there was “a very strong, organized, reactionary attitude” in some segments of the Catholic Church and placed more restrictions on use of the TLM.9 It is not clear if he was reacting to the TLM community as a whole, or was heavily influenced by the online Rad Trad world.
This book, although it spends little time examining the Rad Trad element itself, clearly intends to convey that it is unrepresentative of the TLM movement as a whole. This would potentially assuage critics who were reacting against Rad Trads. And overall, by portraying the TLM adherents as essentially just Catholic only more so, it in effect makes the case for toleration to the Catholic Church hierarchy. Observations such as stressing that “Novus Ordo attendance is very normal and very common among America’s TLM-goers” are very in line with this (p. 129; emphasis original).
The exclusion of SSPX from the study also subtly frames the TLM community as merely a highly committed group of ordinary Catholics as opposed to a problematic, rebellious element. Today, SSPX claims to have approximately thirty-five thousand attendees in the US, about a third of the level of mainstream TLM attendance.10 So, its presence remains substantial, and the shadow of SSPX undoubtedly continues to shape the Catholic Church hierarchy’s view of the TLM.
The authors do ask TLM attendees about SSPX. While many know nothing about it, others rightly acknowledge that the SSPX is the only reason there’s a TLM option at all today, and see the continued existence of SSPX as exerting competitive pressure on the mainstream Church to allow TLM Masses as a legitimate alternative. While the exact relationships and details are complex, it is clear that SSPX remains bound up with TLM practice in American Catholicism at some level.
On the whole, with some limited exceptions like noting elevated levels of support for the death penalty among TLM attenders, the thrust of the book is to portray them as primarily faithful, committed Catholics of the type the Catholic Church might wish all its members were. However, in the very Protestant activity of TLM attenders picking a church based on a personal aesthetic, stylistic, and affinity preference, there is a reason for the Catholic Church hierarchy to see something off about it.
In speculating about the future of the TLM, the authors predict that Traditionis custodes, the Pope Francis document restricting the TLM, would not be formally repealed, but that its application is likely to be liberalized. Regardless of what actually does happen, the TLM is unlikely to be going anywhere. Pope Francis’s TLM restrictions do not apply to the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP), a society formed by returning SSPX priests in the 1980s, or the Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest (ICKSP), another society. FSSP, in particular, was founded on a papal promise that if its priests returned from SSPX, they would be allowed to perform the TLM. The ICKSP also seems to have a papal blessing for performing the TLM. The Trads book does not provide a breakdown of attendance between the societies and ordinary diocesan TLM Mass attendees. But the authors note multiple large FSSP locations, such as Mater Dei Catholic Parish in Irving, Texas. At the same average attendance as SSPX, FSSP would have 31,300 weekly attendees.11 Adding some smaller amount for ICKSP, whose US priest count is not publicly posted, my rough estimate would be that about 40 percent of weekly TLM attendees are via the societies, which are largely unaffected by Traditionis custodes. In other words, a continued supply of TLM Masses is largely guaranteed. At the same time, the growth in traditionalist communities across the religious landscape seems likely to continue under present cultural conditions. Thus, demand will remain strong as well.
With most US Christian denominations facing significant decline in the future, traditionalist segments like the TLM will be one of the rare areas of growth. While TLM communities are much smaller than their mainstream brethren, the shrinkage of the mainstream combined with growth of traditionalists will shift the center of gravity more in the traditionalist direction. This is very likely to produce continued or even increased conflicts between the two groups, and ensure that the TLM remains a topic of discussion and debate for many years to come.
Notes
- ↩
Ruth Graham, “Orthodox Church Pews Are Overflowing with Converts,” New York Times, November 19, 2025, https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/19/us/orthodox-christianity.html.
- ↩
Ruth Graham, “Old Latin Mass Finds New American Audience, Despite Pope’s Disapproval,” New York Times, November 15, 2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/15/us/latin-mass-revival.html.
- ↩
Ross Douthat, “No, Young Men Are Not Returning to Church,” interview with Ryan Burge, Interesting Times, podcast, New York Times, January 22, 2026, https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/22/opinion/interesting-times-ryan-burge.html.
- ↩
Graham Ambrose, “SSPX Situation Is CRAZY. An Orthodox Perspective,” Ironogeist (Substack), June 28, 2026, https://ironogeist.substack.com/p/sspx-situation-is-crazy-an-orthodox.
- ↩
Jake Meador, “Is the Era of Mere Christianity Over?,” Mere Orthodoxy, July 15, 2026, https://mereorthodoxy.com/is-the-era-of-mere-christianity-over/.
- ↩
Stephen Cranney and Stephen Bullivant, Trads: Latin Mass Catholics in the United States (Oxford University Press, 2026).
- ↩
Ryan Burge, “Are ‘Real’ Catholics as Conservative as Evangelicals?,” Graphs About Religion (Substack), May 25, 2026, https://www.graphsaboutreligion.com/p/are-real-catholics-as-conservative.
- ↩
Gregory A. Smith, “Just One-Third of U.S. Catholics Agree with Their Church That Eucharist Is Body, Blood of Christ,” Pew Research Center, August 5, 2019, https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2019/08/05/transubstantiation-eucharist-u-s-catholics/.
- ↩
Ruth Graham, “Pope’s Remarks on ‘Reactionary’ U.S. Catholics Rankle, and Resonate,” New York Times, September 1, 2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/01/us/pope-francis-conservative.html.
- ↩
Society of Saint Pius X, “General Statistics About the SSPX,” updated August 2026, https://sspx.org/en/general-statistics-about-sspx-30870.
- ↩
SSPX has 142 American priests, for a ratio of 247 attendees per priest. FSSP has 127 American priests. At the same ratio, this would equate to about 31,300 attendees. See Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter, “Figures,” statistics as of November 1, 2025, https://www.fssp.org/en/presentation-2/figures/.
